What size bully stick should I get for my dog?
Every treat we make is made in our own USDA-inspected kitchen in Eldred, Pennsylvania, from 100% USA-sourced ingredients.
The right bully stick size depends on your dog's weight, jaw strength, and how they chew. Small dogs and puppies do best with thin or steer cuts. Most medium dogs do well with a regular or thick stick. Large dogs and power chewers need a thick, jumbo, or braided stick. Thickness matters more than length. A stick that is too large or too small is harder for a dog to chew safely.
Does thickness matter more than length?
Yes. Thickness is what a dog's jaw has to work against, so it sets how hard the chew is and how long it lasts. Length sets how much there is and how easy the stick is to hold. We cut bully sticks in several thicknesses: thin and steer for small mouths, then regular, thick, and jumbo. Lengths run four, five, six, and twelve inches. Match thickness to your dog's jaw first, then pick a length your dog can manage.
What size bully stick is best for a small dog or a puppy?
Thin or steer, in six or twelve inches. Small breeds have small jaws, and our product pages are direct about which sticks are cut for them. The 6" Thin Bully Sticks are "pencil-thin, easy for small jaws." The 6" Steer Bully Sticks are "cut short and slim for puppies and small dogs" and "sized for small mouths." If your small dog likes to settle in, the 12" Thin Bully Sticks and 12" Steer Bully Sticks give a full twelve inches that is "long enough to pin down and work on, slim enough for a small jaw." The 4" Regular Bully Sticks are "our shortest standard cut, made for small dogs and easy to hand out during training."
Puppies start on the same slim cuts, no matter how big they will grow. Our 5" Thin Bully Sticks are "cut to suit puppies and small dogs" and "small enough to use as a training reward." Every puppy develops at a different pace, so ask your veterinarian when yours is ready for a firm chew.
Skip the jumbo and braided sticks for a small dog. They are usually too much for a small jaw to make progress on, and a chew a dog cannot make progress on is just frustrating.
Curly sticks are the exception that works across sizes. The 6" Curly Bully Sticks "suit small, medium and large dogs," and the spiral is "easy to grab and hold."
What size bully stick is best for a medium dog?
Regular for an everyday chew, thick when a regular one goes too fast. The 6" Regular Bully Sticks are "the middle-of-the-road choice for most dogs" and "our most ordered bully stick, and the easiest one to start with." The 12" Regular Bully Sticks are "our most popular length."
If a regular stick "disappears too quickly," the 6" Thick Bully Sticks are "a heavier cut at a manageable length, made for medium and large dogs," and the 4" Thick Bully Sticks are "sized for medium and large dogs who go through a thin stick in minutes." The 4" Jumbo Bully Sticks give "medium and large dogs a dense chew without a long stick to manage."
What size bully stick is best for a large dog or a power chewer?
Thick, jumbo, or braided, usually in twelve inches. Our 12" Thick Bully Sticks are "sized for medium and large dogs who make short work of a standard stick." Our 12" Jumbo Bully Sticks are "our heaviest straight cut, made for large dogs with serious jaws." The 6" Jumbo Bully Sticks pack "our heaviest thickness into a shorter stick," with "all the bulk of a jumbo stick in a size that stores easily."
For the longest chew, go braided. The 12" Braided Bully Sticks are "three strands braided into one dense chew," "sized for large dogs," and "the longest-lasting shape we make at this length." The 6" Braided Bully Sticks and the 4" Pretzel Bully Stick are both "for dogs over 20 lbs," and the 12" Jumbo Curly Bully Stick is "for dogs over 25 lbs."
Can a bully stick be too big or too small?
Yes, both ways. As our 6" Regular Bully Sticks – Pack of 10 page puts it, "a stick that is too large or too small is harder for a dog to chew safely." Too small, and a dog can get the whole thing in their mouth and try to swallow it. Too thin for a big dog, and the stick is gone in minutes. Too thick for a small dog, and they cannot make progress at all.
Whatever size you choose, stay nearby while your dog chews and take away the last small piece once it could be swallowed whole. If your dog has ever had a piece stuck or a stomach upset after a chew, ask your veterinarian before you size up or down.
What if I am not sure which size to get?
Start with the everyday size, or try a mix. The 6" Regular Bully Sticks are "the easiest one to start with," and the 12" Regular Bully Sticks page says, "if you are not sure where to start, start here." If you have more than one dog, or you want to compare shapes, the 4lbs. Assorted Bully Sticks give you "sizes from 1 inch to 12 inches in one box," which "covers puppies through large dogs" and is "a practical way to cover a multi-dog household, or to find out which size and shape your dog actually prefers."
Which Preen Pets treat should I choose?
A size-by-size summary, using the wording from each product page. Each beef stick listed below shows one ingredient on its page, 100% beef or 100% bull pizzle, and is high in protein, low in fat, from free-range, grass-fed, USDA approved beef, with no additives, preservatives, hormones, or steroids.
- Puppies and very small dogs: 5" Thin Bully Sticks ("for puppies and small dogs"), 6" Thin Bully Sticks ("pencil-thin, easy for small jaws"), 6" Steer Bully Sticks ("sized for small mouths").
- Small dogs who like a longer session: 12" Thin Bully Sticks ("long enough to hold down with both paws"), 12" Steer Bully Sticks ("long enough to pin down and work on, slim enough for a small jaw").
- Small dogs in training: 4" Regular Bully Sticks ("sized for small dogs and easy to hand out during training").
- Most medium dogs: 6" Regular Bully Sticks ("the middle-of-the-road choice for most dogs") or 12" Regular Bully Sticks ("our most popular length").
- Medium and large dogs who chew fast: 6" Thick Bully Sticks, 12" Thick Bully Sticks, 4" Thick Bully Sticks, or 4" Jumbo Bully Sticks.
- Large dogs with serious jaws: 6" Jumbo Bully Sticks, 12" Jumbo Bully Sticks, or the 12" Jumbo Curly Bully Stick ("for dogs over 25 lbs").
- The longest-lasting shapes: 6" Braided Bully Sticks and the 4" Pretzel Bully Stick ("for dogs over 20 lbs"), and 12" Braided Bully Sticks ("sized for large dogs").
- Any size dog who likes to hold a chew: 6" Curly Bully Sticks or 12" Curly Bully Sticks ("suits small, medium and large dogs").
- Not sure yet: 4lbs. Assorted Bully Sticks.
All are sold in packs and made in our own USDA-inspected kitchen in Eldred, Pennsylvania.
What is the next step?
Open our bully sticks collection and pick the thickness that fits your dog, or take the guesswork out with the assorted box.

